The Fire Island Hotel

25 Cayuga Walk, Ocean Bay Park, Ocean Beach, Fire Island, 11770, NY

Enter Your Trip Dates

1 Room / 2 Adults

1 rooms,
2 adults
  • Rooms:

  • Adults:

  • Close

TripAdvisor Rating


Perched atop a dune overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, this casual hotel offers guests a choice of traditional rooms, family suites, and spacious cottages, all with private outdoor terraces and many with ocean views. While not a lux resort, the Fire Island Hotel is a peaceful, beachfront haven located at the end of a quiet street in Ocean Bay Park.

In the morning, grab a coffee and a bagel at Bootlegger’s Lobby Lounge before spending the day basking on the soft, white sandy beach just a short stroll down the hotel’s boardwalk. Later, take a swim in the only hotel pool on Fire Island, relax with a cocktail from the poolside tiki bar, or grab some dinner at Hurricane’s Bar and Grill. Everything you’ll need for a beach escape is right here.

Our Editor Loves

  • Great oceanfront location
  • Outdoor pool and easy beach access
  • Fun onsite dining

Family Interests

  • Beach

Family Amenities

  • Family Room 5+
  • Onsite Dining
  • Pool


A Much Needed Getaway

by terry s

Following a spring/summer of family emergencies and uncertainties, I greatly looked forward once again to my annual post-season respite (going on 40 yrs) to the Fire Island Hotel. I was not disappointed. Normally staying two nights, I was lucky my room was available for a third night (after nine hours travel time). New Manager, Peter, his staff, including Lacey, Olivia & Bret , were more than accommodating and the weather super. My annual trips to the Lighthouse and the Sunken Forest were (as always) a treasure. I look forward to my return in 2020. Thank you!

Beach weekend

by Lisa B

Hotel staff was very friendly and extremely helpful. Beach was so close it was worth every penny we spent. Rooms were nothing fancy, we had the 2 room suite. TV wasn't hi def and only had 10 channels but with a pool and the ocean who needs TV anyway. Would definitely go back.