Mohonk Mountain House Review

TripAdvisor Rating: TripAdvisor Owl
602 Family Reviews
1000 Mountain Rest Rd., New Paltz NY 12561
81 %
Families Recommend

Enter dates for best prices
Enter dates for best prices

We search 200+ sites to find the best hotel prices

Families Rating
Families Recommend
Editor's Rating
Money Value:
Pool & Water Fun:
Kid Activities:
Kids Play Area:

Editor’s Review of Mohonk Mountain House

New Paltz, NY

From the approach -- and from almost every vantage point -- Mohonk Mountain House cuts a stunning profile. Picture an enormous Victorian castle on a lake, surrounded by lush gardens and situated amid 7,800 acres of nature preserve and nestled on a ridge in the Shawangunk mountains (one of the Nature Conservancy's "Last Great Places" on earth.)

It's a spectacular setting, and quite a story: At more than 140 years old, Mohonk Mountain House is one of the last of the great grand resorts of its ilk. The hotel's bona fides include designations as a National Historic Landmark and a place on the register of Historic Hotels. George Washington didn't sleep here but five presidents have (Roosevelt, Hayes, Taft, Arthur
... more and Clinton).

Mohonk's legacy began in 1869 with the identical twin Smiley brothers, eccentric and frugal Quakers and educators who had a vision and who made some good choices and got lucky. They -- particularly brother Albert -- envisaged Mohonk as a summer retreat where people could reap the benefits of communing with nature and with each other. For many years, Mohonk was a hub of academic and diplomatic conferences and refined entertainment. It faltered in a few periods but has rebounded to its position today as one of America's great historic resorts.

Architecturally, Mohonk is an outlandish amalgamation: nine adjoining buildings of various periods, facades, heights, angles, turrets and towers, more than an eighth of a mile from end-to-end. With all its eclecticism there is a coherence to the place. The 2005 Spa Wing isn't an aesthetic jolt from the 1879 Rock Building it adjoins; the 2001 Skating Pavilion nicely echoes the feel of the main dining room wing that dates to the turn of the last century. Somehow it all hangs together.

Mohonk's interiors are equally historic and eclectic. Fixtures, carpeting, furniture and decor are either original or reproduction period pieces comfortably arranged in vast public spaces and the dozens of cozy nooks throughout the seven-story hotel. Hallways serve as a kind of vertical scrapbook, with photographs, paintings, maps, textiles, news clippings, floor plans and artifacts of the hotel's history and geography, worthy of taking the time to review.

Mohonk occasionally gets comparisons to the haunted Overlook Hotel in The Shining. Perhaps it's the Victorian feel or scale of the place or expansive hallways or its topiary maze. But from there the comparison fall short. The only "ghost" here is likely the spirit of Albert Smiley, who probably would be quite pleased with the way the place has evolved -- and the ways in which it has not. With a 140-year-old resort, the art form is in knowing what to change, and what to keep the same. Mohonk largely gets the balance right.

Mohonk is special as much for what it is not as for what it is. It is decidedly low-tech. You won't be assaulted by flat-screen TVs in every corner, nor will you have one in your room. Daily schedules are still tacked to bulletin boards. The airwaves aren't yet permeated with Wi-Fi.

Four o'clock isn't happy hour at Mohonk; it's tea-and-cookies time. The resort's only bar (a recent concession to modern sensibilities) closes at 11. Alan Alda is about the hottest celebrity sighting reported there. And the only glitz you're likely to see is in a craft bin at the kids club. Mohonk is so un-cool, it's cool.

To love Mohonk is to appreciate the whole experience -- its gorgeous setting and natural beauty and classic take on relaxation and recreation and service. Avoid getting too fussed about particular details -- uneven dinner service, the lack of technology, how long you may have to wait for your car -- or you'll likely begin to have serious problems with the price point (not cheap). less
Our Editor Loves
  • Family-friendly atmosphere
  • All-inclusive rates and three bountiful meals a day
  • Spectacular setting and great array of outdoor activities
Family Interests
  • All Inclusive
  • Bicycling
  • Golf
  • Hiking
  • Skiing
Family Amenities
  • Babysitting
  • Cribs
  • DVD Player
  • Pool
Our Member Reviews 602 Reviews
A Fantastic Getaway
Reviewed on 08/08/2011
Mohonk Mountain House has been the highlight oh my familie's year for the past 15 years. We go for a week during the summer every year. We go with my entire family, meaning about 24 people. When we wake up in the morning the ...
Read full review


As a TripAdvisor company, we searched 200+ sites to find the best hotel prices.

Enter dates for best prices
Enter dates for best prices

Compare best prices from the top travel sites


There are 265 guest rooms on seven floors and the range of sizes, styles and features reflects the eclecticism of the hotel itself. The basic room categories are Traditional, Victorian, Suites/Junior Suites and Tower Rooms. Even within these categories, the room can vary in size and features, and be sizes and bedding combinations. Many have balconies and many have in-room fireplaces (some have both). With a supply of chopped wood, firestarters and easy instructions, this former Girl Scout got a minor blaze going in no time. There are no TVs in the rooms -- to the discontent of some but a welcome opportunity for your kids to detox from Spongebob Square Pants.

Many of Mohonk's rooms have been refurbished over the past several years. Upgrades include new furniture, fixtures, carpeting and window treatments and air conditioning -- a fairly recent addition the Mountain House.

Bathrooms are stocked with Mohonk's house brand of rosemary mint shampoo, conditioner and shower gel.


Traveling Family with Baby

Your personal family vacation planning starts now

Get expert advice, handpicked recommendations, and tips for your family all year round!