Amara Cay Resort

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, 33036, FL

Best Prices for Your Stay

  • 1 Rooms,
  • 1 Adults

Enter Dates for Best Prices

1 Room / 2 Adults

1 rooms,
2 adults
  • Rooms:

  • Adults:

  • Close

TripAdvisor Rating


Located along the Upper Keys, this oceanfront resort has a beach filled with hammocks. Or if a lounge chair by the pool is more your speed, they have those too. The guestrooms with a king or double bed have a private balcony. The suites have king or queen beds, a sleeper sofa and a drink chiller. There is a $28 per day resort fee but it includes parking, Wi-Fi access and use of beach chairs, pool towels and a shuttle service among other things. There are two onsite restaurants and a playground for the kids.

Our Editor Loves

  • Hammocks on the beach
  • Playground
  • Resort shuttle

Family Interests

  • Beach
  • Museum/Cultural
  • Sailing
  • Water Sports

Family Amenities

  • Onsite Dining
  • Pool


Keys visit

by Kim L

We have been to this property several times for the alligator lighthouse swim in September. The property is spectacular and the accommodations are great. I would highly recommend this resort for anyone coming to the keys! We will definitely be back again! Thank you Amara Cay staff.

Excellent stay

by MDBDell

We stayed at Amara Cay in mid September and it was really nice. Our room overlooked the tiki bar with ocean views - very bright, clean, and well appointed. The pool was very clean and relaxing. We ate at the tiki bar and it was very good. The place has a great relaxing vibe which is exactly what we were looking for. I would stay again.