The American Hotel

49 Main Street, Sag Harbor, 11963, NY

Enter Your Trip Dates

1 Room / 2 Adults

1 rooms,
2 adults
  • Rooms:

  • Adults:

  • Close

TripAdvisor Rating


Located right in the downtown area of Sag Harbor on Main Street, the American Hotel is both a hotel and a restaurant. Enter through the restaurant and stop at the front desk, which doubles as the host stand for diners. There are just eight rooms, but all are spacious and can sleep up to four. Décor is traditional and historic, and rooms still use traditional keys to open. In-room amenities include sitting areas, whirlpool bathtubs, TV’s and free Wi-Fi. Guests receive a free continental breakfast daily, and can dine for lunch or dinner at the restaurant on the first floor (open 8 a.m. to 10 p.m.). The beach and marina are walking distance from the hotel, as are shops and restaurants throughout the downtown area of Sag Harbor. Minimum-night stays may apply in the high season.

Our Editor Loves

  • Old-fashioned hotel and restaurant
  • Complimentary breakfast
  • Great location on Main Street in Sag Harbor

Family Interests

  • Beach
  • Museum/Cultural

Family Amenities

  • Free Breakfast
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Onsite Dining


Great Food and Service

by Robertcopeland

No complaint with the food. The Duck was a large portion cooked just right. The Cesar Salad could have had more anchovies. The bread was to die for. Crispy crusty and just right. Great desert as well.
I know we were fine dining, but I still think the restaurant is pricy.

Historical ambiance - A Landmark with great food!!!

by Debra S

Mmm The Scottish Salmons were perfection and we were indulged with a special vegetarian risotto & a few sides. Our waitress Chloe was a sweetheart. We ate early enough to choose the glass-roofed Atrium with foliage & christmas lights. Ah, don't miss the bar scene & piano man during Autumn! Or the Ladies Room with ancient pull-flush!