by Amanda Geronikos
The Blue Fish Inn is located in the heart of Cape May, New Jersey, a short walk from the beach. Complimentary beach chairs and umbrellas are available. Other perks include complimentary, continental breakfast (served in the summer); a grilling station and picnic area; an outdoor, heated swimming pool; an onsite bike rack; free parking; a coin-operated guest laundry facility; complimentary coffee (served all day); and complimentary Wi-Fi. Need recommendations or help making reservations? Ask the concierge.
Guestrooms are equipped with mini-fridges, while efficiency units have full kitchens. Families should consider the Family Style Two Room Suite, which has a private bedroom with a queen bed and another area with two double beds — sleeping up to six guests. DVD and VHS players can be requested, and pets are welcome in select rooms. All units have shower/tub combos in their bathrooms.
Open year-round, the Blue Fish Inn also offers single-night stays — a rarity in Cape May, as most hotels require two- to three-night minimum stays.
Our Editor Loves
- Family rooms
- Outdoor pool
- Free breakfast
- Family Room 5+
- Free Breakfast
- Free Wi-Fi
This was our first time at this hotel and we couldn't be happier! The hotel rooms and grounds are immaculate! The landscaping is beautiful, the pool is very clean with plenty of chairs for everyone. I was pleasantly surprised at all the little details throughout to help make our stay more comfortable. The pool area offers clean towels, there was a blow dryer in the room, and even a dispenser in the shower for shampoo, conditioner, and body wash. They even have beach chairs or an umbrella you can borrow for the beach! We loved the courtyard in the back of the hotel, it's perfect for a lunch gathering or just to relax with a drink. It is a few blocks from the beach, but we rented bikes and we loved that there was a bike rack in the courtyard to safely keep our bikes. The staff was so friendly and accommodating. We will definitely come again!! Thank you!
by Claire S
This was our first visit to Cape May. We found The Blue Fish Inn on the internet and hoped everything was as good as it sounded. It was more! The rooms and grounds are immaculate. Franco and Lena are wonderful hosts - knowledgeable about the area, friendly, and helpful. Since it was our first time, we just accepted their advice and it proved good every time. Although all rooms were booked when we were there, it was extremely quiet. We are already planning our next trip.